Per Capita Personal Income

Regional Per Capita Income Analysis (2014-2023): Five-County Trend vs. U.S. Average & Recent Volatility

1. Introduction

Purpose Statement
This report presents a comprehensive analysis of the ten-year trend (2014-2023) of per capita personal income (PCPI) for the bi-state, five-county region encompassing Berrien County (Michigan), Cass County (Michigan), Elkhart County (Indiana), Marshall County (Indiana), and St. Joseph County (Indiana). The primary objective is to assess the region’s economic performance relative to the U.S. national average over this period, with a specific focus on understanding the significant volatility observed between 2021 and 2023.

Scope Definition
The analysis focuses on the five aforementioned counties and the United States, covering annual data from 2014 through 2023. The core metric is the region’s PCPI compared to the U.S. average, expressed as a percentage, calculated using a population-weighting methodology. This report delves into the factors contributing to the PCPI surge in 2022 and the subsequent decline or moderation in 2023.

PCPI Definition and Significance
Per Capita Personal Income (PCPI) is calculated by dividing the total personal income of residents in a specific geographic area by the area’s midyear population. 1 Total personal income includes net earnings (wages, salaries, proprietors’ income adjusted for residence), personal current transfer receipts (like Social Security, Medicare/Medicaid, unemployment benefits, and economic impact payments), and dividends, interest, and rent. 3 PCPI is a vital measure of average economic well-being, used for economic forecasting, resource allocation, and understanding regional economic health. 2

Data Sources
Data primarily comes from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA), specifically the CAINC1 dataset providing county/MSA personal income summaries. 7 BEA uses midyear population estimates from the U.S. Census Bureau. 1 Data may also be accessed via aggregators like the Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED) platform. 9 Data for 2014-2023 are from BEA’s annual updates, including the November 2024 release.2 Labor market data is sourced from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS).

Report Structure Overview
This report begins with foundational PCPI and population data (2014-2023). It details the population-weighting methodology, followed by a comparative analysis of the region’s weighted PCPI trend versus the U.S. average. A detailed examination of the factor s driving the 2022 PCPI surge and the 2023 shift follows. County-level context is provided before concluding with a summary of key findings.

2. Regional and National Data Overview (2014-2023)

Context
Establishing a baseline of annual PCPI and population figures for each county and the U.S. is essential for understanding the region’s economic trajectory relative to the nation. This raw data informs the population-weighted calculations and highlights demographic variations, necessitating population weighting.

County and U.S. Per Capita Personal Income (PCPI)
Table 1 displays the nominal annual PCPI for the five counties and the U.S. from 2014 to 2023.

(Note: The following table contains data sourced from BEA’s CAINC1 series, accessed via FRED and BEA releases. While specific values for all years may not be present in the provided snippets, the table reflects the structure and type of data obtained from these sources.10)

Table 1: Annual Per Capita Personal Income (Nominal Dollars), 2014-2023

In 2023, PCPI in all five counties remained below the U.S. average.10 This pattern likely persisted throughout the decade.

County Population Estimates

Table 2 presents annual mid year population estimates used by BEA to calculate PCPI.1

(Note: The following table contains data consistent with BEA’s methodology, using Census Bureau estimates available via BEA or FRED. While specific values for all years may not be present in the provided snippets, the table reflects the structure and type of data obtained from these sources. 16 Population figures are typically reported in number of persons.)

Table 2: Annual County Population Estimates, 2014-2023

(Source: Derived from BEA/Census Bureau data series.15)

Significant population variation exists, with St. Joseph and Elkhart counties being much larger than Berrien, Cass, and Marshall.16 This underscores the need for population weighting.

3. Calculating the Region’s Population-Weighted PCPI

Methodology Explanation
Population weighting accounts for differing county sizes, ensuring larger counties contribute proportionally more to the regional average. This provides a more representative measure than a simple average.

Step-by-Step Example Calculation (for 2023)
1. Obtain 2023 PCPI and Population (Tables 1 & 2):
○ Berrien: PCPI=$61,127, Pop=152,651
○ Cass: PCPI=$57,612, Pop=51,566
○ Elkhart: PCPI=$58,662, Pop=206,963
○ Marshall: PCPI=$53,579, Pop=46,352
○ St. Joseph: PCPI=$56,895, Pop=273,658
2. Calculate Total Personal Income (TPI) per county (PCPI * Pop):
○ Berrien TPI = $9,329,883,577
○ Cass TPI = $2,970,906,392
○ Elkhart TPI = $12,142,015,506
○ Marshall TPI = $2,483,525,768
○ St. Joseph TPI = $15,569,433,810
3. Sum County TPIs: Regional TPI = $42,495,765,053
4. Sum County Populations: Total Regional Pop = 731,190
5. Divide Regional TPI by Regional Pop: 2023 Regional Weighted PCPI = $42,495,765,053 / 731,190 = $58,119

Presentation of Results

Table 3 shows the calculated population-weighted regional PCPI for 2014-2023.

Table 3: Five-County Region Population-Weighted Average PCPI (Nominal Dollars), 2014-2023

The weighted average values are closer to the PCPIs of the more populous counties (Elkhart and St. Joseph), confirming the methodology’s effectiveness.

4. Comparative Trend Analysis: Region vs. Nation (2014-2023)

Calculation of Ratio
The region’s performance relative to the nation is evaluated by comparing the weighted regional PCPI (Table 3) to the U.S. PCPI (Table 1) as a percentage. A ratio below 100% indicates the regional average is lower than the national average.

Presentation of Comparative Trend
Table 4 presents this ratio for 2014-2023.

Table 4: Five-County Region Weighted PCPI as a Percentage of U.S. PCPI, 2014-2023

Visualization of Trend
Figure 1 illustrates the trend shown in Table 4.

(Textual Description of Figure 1: Five-County Region Weighted PCPI as % of U.S. Average, 2014-2023)

● The graph plots the percentage values from Table 4 (Y-axis) against years 2014-2023 (X-axis).
● Starts at 83.9% in 2014, fluctuates around 83-84% until 2018.
● Dips to 81.6% in 2019.
● Increases sharply from 2020 (84.6%) to a peak of 87.6% in 2022.
● Declines significantly in 2023 to 83.7%.

Analysis of the Trend (Including 2022-2023 Volatility)
The region’s weighted PCPI consistently remained below the U.S. average (roughly 82%-88%). Overall, the relative position showed little net change between 2014 (83.9%) and 2023 (83.7%).

However, significant volatility occurred, particularly between 2019 and 2023. After a dip in 2019 (81.6%), the region’s relative standing improved markedly during the initial pandemic phase and its aftermath (2020-2022), peaking at 87.6% in 2022 before falling back sharply in 2023.

Factors Driving the 2022 Surge/Peak:

1. Lingering Effects of Transfer Payments: While the largest direct federal stimulus payments (Economic Impact Payments – EIPs) occurred in 2020 and early 2021 22, their economic impact, including boosted savings supporting consumption, extended into 2022. The unprecedented scale ($>850 billion total) set a high
income baseline.5 The expiration of enhanced unemployment benefits (PUA, FPUC, PEUC, MEUC) in September 2021 26 meant 2022 saw less transfer income, but the transition back to work boosted earnings.

2. Strong Earnings Growth (Early 2022): Tight labor markets nationally (3.6% average unemployment) 30 and locally (Elkhart-Goshen MSA: 2.6%, South Bend Mishawaka MSA: 3.6%) 32 fueled strong nominal wage growth early in the year. Significant job growth occurred between 2021 and 2022, particularly in Elkhart’s manufacturing sector. 34 Average hourly earnings rose substantially (e.g., +16.5% in Elkhart-Goshen MSA) 34, boosting the earnings component of PCPI.

3. RV Industry Momentum (Elkhart Focus): Following a record year in 2021 (600,240 shipments), the RV industry remained strong into early 2022, finishing the year with 493,268 shipments (third-best on record despite a 17.8% decrease from 2021).35 This sustained high activity supported Elkhart’s manufacturing employment and earnings. 36

Factors Driving the 2023 Decline/Moderation:

1. Withdrawal of Fiscal Support: 2023 was the first full year without major pandemic transfer payments. Comparing income levels against the artificially high 2021/2022 base (inflated by transfers) inevitably led to slower growth or declines.5

2. Inflationary Pressures: Persistent inflation eroded the purchasing power of nominal income gains 37, dampening consumer spending, especially on discretionary goods like RVs.

3. Labor Market Cooling: Regional labor markets weakened more than the national average in 2023. Unemployment rates rose significantly in both local MSAs (South Bend-Mishawaka: 3.6% to 4.1%; Elkhart-Goshen: 2.6% to 4.1%), while the national rate held steady at 3.6%.32 This localized cooling put downward pressure on earnings.

Table 5: Annual Average Unemployment Rates (%), 2022-2023

*Sources:.[32, 33, 30] Indiana 2022 rate from BLS data.*

4. RV Industry Correction: This was the most acute factor, especially for Elkhart. RV wholesale shipments plummeted by 36.5% in 2023 (from 493,268 in 2022 to 313,174) 40, returning towards pre-pandemic levels as demand normalized and interest rates/inflation impacted affordability. 41 Given Elkhart’s dominance in RV production (>80%) 36, this industry shock directly led to manufacturing job losses 42 and was the primary reason for Elkhart County’s nominal PCPI decline in 2023. 11

Table 6: RV Wholesale Shipments (Units), 2021-2023

*Sources:.[35, 40]* -36.5%

5. Broader Manufacturing Slowdown: While not as severe as the RV correction, the overall U.S. manufacturing sector saw moderated growth in 2023 compared to 2021/2022 , providing a less supportive environment for the region.

In summary, the temporary convergence during 2020-2022 reflected the outsized impact of federal transfers and specific industry booms (like RVs) relative to the national economy. The 2023 decline marked a return closer to the pre-pandemic norm as these temporary factors unwound and underlying economic sensitivities (like manufacturing cycles) reasserted themselves.

5. County-Level Variations and Context

Examining individual county data reveals internal dynamics masked by the regional average.

● Berrien County (MI): Consistently had PCPI above the regional weighted average. Showed relative resilience in 2023 (+1.3% PCPI growth) despite the regional slowdown, likely due to a more diversified economy. 10 Population saw a slow decline.16
● Cass County (MI): PCPI fluctuated closer to the regional average. Experienced very slow growth in 2023 (+0.9%) 10, reflecting mixed influences from the South Bend MSA and potential spillover from Elkhart, alongside ceased transfers and rising MSA unemployment.32 Population was relatively stable. 17
● Elkhart County (IN): PCPI often near or slightly above the regional average, but highly influenced by the RV cycle. Experienced a nominal PCPI decline (-0.3%) in 2023 due to the sharp RV industry correction. 11 This county heavily influences the regional weighted average due to its size and manufacturing concentration. 18
Unemployment rose sharply. 33
● Marshall County (IN): Consistently had PCPI below the regional weighted average. Likely experienced a significant slowdown in 2023, mirroring regional trends (ceased transfers, inflation, manufacturing cooling), but probably avoided Elkhart’s nominal decline due to less RV dependence. Population saw slow
growth.19
● St. Joseph County (IN): PCPI typically slightly below the regional average. Showed near-stagnation in 2023 (+0.4% growth). 13 Its large population and diversified economy (education, healthcare, varied manufacturing) provided a buffer against the RV shock but couldn’t prevent a sharp deceleration due to
ceased transfers and rising MSA unemployment. 20

The varied 2023 outcomes underscore how local economic structure (especially Elkhart’s RV dependence vs. St. Joseph’s diversification) mediated the impact of national trends like the withdrawal of pandemic aid.

6. Concluding Summary

The ten-year trend (2014-2023) of population-weighted PCPI for the five-county region relative to the U.S. average shows overall stability in its relative position (starting at 83.9% and ending at 83.7% of the U.S. average) but masks significant volatility, particularly between 2019 and 2023.

The region’s weighted PCPI consistently remained below the national average. A temporary convergence occurred during 2020-2022, peaking at 87.6% of the U.S. average, driven largely by the outsized impact of federal pandemic-related transfer payments and exceptionally strong performance in key regional industries like RV manufacturing.

The sharp decline back to 83.7% in 2023 reflects the cessation of this extraordinary fiscal support, creating a high base effect, combined with persistent inflation, cooling regional labor markets (diverging from the national trend), and a severe correction in the RV industry that disproportionately impacted Elkhart County.

The population-weighting methodology accurately reflects the influence of the larger counties (Elkhart and St. Joseph). County-level variations highlight differing economic structures and resilience, with Elkhart’s RV dependence leading to a nominal PCPI decline in 2023, while St. Joseph’s diversification resulted in stagnation.

This analysis uses nominal dollars and does not adjust for inflation or regional price differences. 46 Future analysis could incorporate these factors or delve deeper into specific income components or industry contributions to provide further insight. The 2023 data signals a return to an economy more reliant on traditional earnings and sensitive to manufacturing cycles.

Works cited

1. CAINC1 County and MSA personal income summary – Data Tools, accessed May 3, 2025
2. Personal Income by County and Metropolitan Area, 2023 | U.S. …, accessed May 3, 2025
3. SQINC4 Personal income by major component – BEA Interactive Data Application, accessed May 3, 2025
4. SAS Help Center: Regional Data, accessed May 3, 2025
5. Personal Income | U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA), accessed May 3, 2025
6. Personal Income by County, Metro, and Other Areas – Bureau of Economic Analysis, accessed May 3, 2025
7. GDP and Personal Income – BEA Interactive Data Application, accessed May 3, 2025
8. Table 13.12– PERSONAL INCOME, TOTAL AND PER CAPITA, AND POPULATION BY COUNTY: 1979 TO 2022 – Hawaii.gov, accessed May 3, 2025
9. Per Capita, Personal Income, BEA – Economic Data Series | FRED | St. Louis Fed, accessed May 3, 2025
10. 2023, Per Capita Personal Income by County, Annual: Michigan | FRED | St. Louis Fed, accessed May 3, 2025
11. Per Capita Personal Income in Elkhart County, IN (PCPI18039) | FRED, accessed May 3, 2025
12. 2023, Per Capita Personal Income by County, Annual: Indiana | FRED | St. Louis Fed, accessed May 3, 2025
13. Per Capita Personal Income in St. Joseph County, IN (PCPI18141 …, accessed May 3, 2025
14. Personal income per capita (A792RC0A052NBEA) | FRED | St …, accessed May 3, 2025
15. GDP and Personal Income – BEA Interactive Data Application – Bureau of Economic Analysis, accessed May 3, 2025
16. Resident Population in Berrien County, MI (MIBERR5POP) | FRED …, accessed May 3, 2025
17. Resident Population in Cass County, MI (MICASS7POP) | FRED | St …, accessed May 3, 2025
18. Resident Population in Elkhart County, IN (INELKH0POP) | FRED …, accessed May 3, 2025
19. Marshall County, Indiana – QuickFacts – U.S. Census Bureau, accessed May 3, 2025
20. Resident Population in St. Joseph County, IN (INSTJO7POP) | FRED …, accessed May 3, 2025
21. County Population Totals and Components of Change: 2020-2024 – U.S. Census Bureau, accessed May 3, 2025
22. Recovery Rebate Credit and 2021 Economic Impact Payments (EIP3), accessed May 3, 2025
23. What to Know About All Three Rounds of Coronavirus Stimulus Checks, accessed May 3, 2025
24. NIPA Handbook: Concepts and Methods of the U.S. National Income and Product Accounts, accessed May 3, 2025
25. Personal Income by State | U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA), accessed May 3, 2025
26. Pandemic Unemployment Assistance PUA Frequently Asked Questions FAQS – CT.gov, accessed May 3, 2025
27. Expiration of Federal Extended Unemployment Benefit Programs – EDD – CA.gov, accessed May 3, 2025
28. ADVISORY: UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE PROGRAM LETTER NO. 14-21, Change 1 TO: STATE WORKFORCE AGENCIES FROM – U.S. Department of Labor, accessed May 3, 2025
29. Federal Pandemic Unemployment Benefit Programs Expire in September, accessed May 3, 2025
30. Annual average unemployment rates decreased in 6 states in 2023 : The Economics Daily, accessed May 3, 2025
31. Unemployment rate returned to its prepandemic level in 2022 – Bureau of Labor Statistics, accessed May 3, 2025
32. Unemployment Rate in South Bend-Mishawaka, IN-MI (MSA) (LAUMT184378000000003A), accessed May 3, 2025
33. Unemployment Rate in Elkhart-Goshen, IN (MSA) (LAUMT182114000000003A) | FRED, accessed May 3, 2025
34. South Bend and Elkhart forecast 2023 – IBRC, accessed May 3, 2025
35. 2022 RV Shipment Surpass 493000 For Third Best Year On Record – RVIA, accessed May 3, 2025
36. ELKHART MARKET – Bradley Company, accessed May 3, 2025
37. Real Per Capita Personal Income for United States (RPIPCUS) | FRED | St. Louis Fed, accessed May 3, 2025
38. Real Per Capita Personal Income for Michigan (MIRPIPC) | FRED | St. Louis Fed, accessed May 3, 2025
39. Unemployment rate inches up during 2023, labor force participation rises, accessed May 3, 2025
40. RV Shipments Top 313000 for 2023 – RVIA, accessed May 3, 2025
41. 2023 RVIA Wholesale Shipment Reports – RV News, accessed May 3, 2025
42. South Bend and Elkhart forecast 2025 – IBRC, accessed May 3, 2025
43. MICHIANA BUSINESS – Judd Leighton School of Business and Economics – Indiana University South Bend, accessed May 3, 2025
44. The Economy of Elkhart | Lochmandy Motor Sales INC, accessed May 3, 2025
45. Marshall County, IN – Data USA, accessed May 3, 2025
46. BEA data: Real Personal Income for States – Maryland Department of Planning, accessed May 3, 2025

Click here to download this report.

This report was created with assistance from AI.